The only way that I can cope with the New England Patriots Super Bowl XLVI defeat this morning is to focus solely on the ads. Overall quality and entertainment of ads was down this year, but three themes of significance for communicators and one clear winner for its targeted message and online experience stand out.
Three Trends and One Winner
1. Ubiquitous and Unique Hash Tags
Advertisers made sure that the entire experience—from pre-game “leaks” to the in-game 30 second spot to online chatter—united around one theme. The use of clever hash tags was no exception. Audi carried its Vampire theme over to its hashtag #solongvampires. GE tried to get people talking about #whatworks after showcasing how its people and factories create great, useful stuff, like the turbines that create beer.
While the hash tags were fun to comment on in real time, did they have an impact on the conversation around the brand? Somewhat. Cute or complicated hash tags may have just made it a bit too tricky for Tweeters to make use of it. For example, mentions of Audi were 50% higher than that of its hash tag. So what have we learned here? Clever hash tags might be fun to brainstorm, but for the “Big Game” where buzz around the brand is key, it might make more sense to just stick with your brand or company name.
2. Employees as the Voice of the Company
Employees—and factories—took center stage in this year’s crop of Super Bowl ads. Eager to demonstrate a commitment to America’s people and products, companies like GE, Best Buy, Turbo Tax, and even NBC Sports let their people share why they love the work that they do and how it contributes to improving the American way of life. Here at CEC we say “Bravo!” Why not tap into the passion of your employees (that passion must exist, of course, before you can harness it) and share an authentic message?
3. Fellow Consumers and Cool Experiences Tap into our Emotion
An emotional connection with the company—be it in the form of shared values or some other feeling of ownership or investment—is the number one driver of a stakeholder actively supporting your company by sharing that positive sentiment with their friends (CEC Influencing Stakeholders, 2010).
Companies tapped into this emotional connection to drive conversation around their brand in two ways. First, Doritos, as it did last year, handed over the commercial-creation reigns to its consumers. The wildly funny Doritos “Slingshot Baby” by chip eater Kevin Wilson and the number-one ranked “Man’s Best Friend” by Jonathan Friedman showcased the fantasies of Doritos lovers. Second, other companies, notably Cadillac and Chevrolet showcased their car operating under “extreme circumstances.” Cadillac featured its ATS driving circles around competitors on Germany’s “Green Hell” while Chevy let boys be boys and take the Chevy Sonic bungee jumping, sky diving, and making a music video with OK Go.
Taken together, each of these trends bear witness to the maturation of Marketers and Advertisers continued navigation of the labyrinth of online vs. TV, social vs. promotional, and entertaining vs. informational. Given the complexity and the cost, what do you think the future of Super Bowl advertising looks like?
And the winner is…
Honda CRV
Why it works:
- Stakeholder-centric: This ad didn’t so much as target a demographic as it did a psychographic: anyone who’s feeling a bit antsy about taking the next “big leap” in life and worried that they won’t get to do all those fun things before saddled with life’s obligations.
- Integrated with social…in a way that people want: So lots of ads (if not all?) were designed to get viewers participating in online conversations about the company or product, especially via Facebook. The site for the CRV wins, in my opinion, because it invites visitors to share something we love sharing anyway: our dreams. “Before I make the next leap in life…” makes it easy for people to share and fun for those visiting the site to see what their peers are dreaming of. Unsurprisingly, trips to Europe, running a marathon, and learning a new language top the list.
- And yes, Company-centric: Most of us remember the commercials, but not the names of the companies behind them. In both the Ferris Bueller-inspired (mimicked exactly?) “Matthew’s Day Off” spot and others, I thought Honda did a good job of showcasing the car that is designed to help each of us fulfill our leap lists.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=VhkDdayA4iA
So what’s your take? What other trends did you notice? Which ads were HORRIBLE? Which ones made you laugh?
Other Favorites:
- Cars.com “Neck” had me singing “Ooh, baby I want that car” all evening. Can I download it on iTunes?
- M&M’s “Just my Shell”: it was fun and funny, and I like the song. A good, happy moment in some otherwise “heavy” ads.
Worst Ads:
- Coca Cola’s Polar Bear spots seemed wildly out of touch with this year’s mild winter in North America.
- Bud Light Platinum. Looking just like the Bud Light you buy in an aluminum bottle at a Nats game, Bud Light Platinum missed a huge chance to differentiate itself. Wouldn’t you like to know it has 2% more alcohol than Bud Light? Or that it was a blue glass bottle on the screen?
CEC Related Resources
- Boost Your Audience Understanding
- US Stakeholders: A look behind behaviors
- Global Stakeholders: A look behind behaviors
CEC Related Blogs

Red Dawn seems to have all the ingredients of a surefire Hollywood success. It’s a remake of a successful 1984 film featuring Charlie Sheen and Patrick Swayze about a group of teenagers banding together to save their small U.S. town from a Soviet invasion. The new cast of up and coming stars have already been featured in blockbusters like Thor and Transformers and seem tailor made to appeal to the tween and teen audiences that have fueled recent hits like Twilight and Harry Potter. So why is MGM spending more than a million dollars to digitally edit the finished film and delay its release until November 2012? Because in the new version the invading force is a Chinese army, and in Hollywood today, you do not want to upset the Chinese, who sanction only 20 foreign movie releases per year. (The “digitally re-mastered” enemy moviegoers will see is led by a much less commercially important North Korean force).
There has been a rapid growth in available communications channels in the last couple years. This channel explosion places an unprecedented pressure on the communications function to design a strong channel strategy to use these efficiently and effectively. All of these new channels present an opportunity for communicators to reach out to large audiences and spread information and messages with rapid speed. But it also takes lots of more of communicator’s time to navigate these channels and measure and evaluate how effective they are in their usage.
This blog is part of our
This blog is part of our
This blog is part of our
As soon clock struck midnight a few weeks ago on January 1st, many of us vowed to change ourselves for the better. We thought, “Ah January, a fresh start to a brand spankin’ new year. 2011 is out and 2012 is IN BABY!” We vowed to lose weight, eat healthier, and take that trip we’ve been talking about for years. We made a COMMITMENT to self-improvement otherwise known as a New Year’s Resolution.
Do you enjoy building relationships and view conflict a positive means of arriving at a solution? Are you comforable addressing potentially contentious issues, but find that data and tools make you anxious? Do you recognize the power and relevance of communication measurement methods, but struggle to contextualize data into recommendations or actions? If you answered “yes” to any of the above, chances are that you’re an “Influencer.”
Communicators often need to use numbers to narrate a story. However, for people who love playing with words, it can be a “scary” prospect to conduct quantitative surveys. The challenge lies in asking the right set of questions, gathering information that meets the desired objectives, and analyzing the data to build your story. The question then becomes, “What is the best way to gather the information required to fulfill my desired objectives?”
As we close the book on 2011, most of us are probably drafting our plans for how we intend to achieve our 2012 objectives. If you’re like many of the communicators who I have spoken with recently, you are eager to structure your communication plans so as to demonstrate the value that Communications can create for rest of the business. Perhaps you’re even using the CEC’s recently published toolkit on